Though my web site primarily emphasizes matrix surround sound systems, there are many other types of surround systems. What follows, is a quick overview of some of the other implementations of surround sound currently available.
Dolby Surround
Plain "Dolby Surround" is much like matrix surround.
There are some key differences however. Dolby Surround limits the
frequency response of the rear speakers. Frequencies above 7 kHz
are suppressed in order to reduce front-to-back channel leakage
of upper octave information. (It is debatable as to whether or
not this frequency suppression is really needed or desirable.)
Also, Dolby Surround delays the audio signal sent to the rear
speakers. (Typically by about 20 milliseconds.) This allows your
brain to better lock on to the sounds that should be primarily
coming from the front speakers. Much more information can be
found by reviewing Dolby's own web site.
Dolby Pro-logic
Dolby Pro-logic has two basic enhancements over regular Dolby
Surround. First, a front center channel is added providing 3
distinct front sound sources (left, center, and right). This is
very beneficial when watching a TV program or movie as the dialog
will come from where the screen is located for all listeners--even
those off center from the listening area. Secondly, "steering
logic" is added. This "steering logic" can
dynamically adjust the volume of any one channel at a time. Thus
the separation between channels is significantly enhanced. Note,
however, that this steering logic can possibly cause problems
when listening to music-only or other non-Dolby Surround sound
material. If you have a "Pro-Logic" receiver and are
listening to any stereo source that is not specifically encoded
in Dolby Surround, you may wish to set your surround decoder to a
mode other than the Pro-Logic setting. Do this if the music or
sound seems to unnaturally bounce around from one channel to
another. As mention in the paragraph above, Dolby has an
excellent web site covering much of their technological
innovations. Dolby's home page is at:
www.dolby.com.
Dolby Digital
This surround sound technology is incompatible with regular
stereo source material. That is, it requires a digital data
stream specially formatted using Dolby's AC-3 (5.1 channel)
surround format. Currently Dolby Digital can be found in HDTV (High
Definition Television), DVD (Digital Video Disks), and in some
DSS (Digital Satellite) systems. Many new stereo receivers now
incorporate Dolby Digital decoders. Because of its use in DVD and
HDTV, Dolby Digital has a bright future.
Dolby Digital provides 5 full range discrete channels along with a "bass effects" sub-woofer channel. It's the current state-of-the-art standard in movie surround sound. If you are going to be buying a new stereo receiver within the next few years, get one with Dolby Digital. (Receivers with Dolby Digital technology also include Dolby Pro-Logic and often include one or more basic surround sound modes.)
Virtual Surround Sound Technologies
A number of different technologies and companies (including Dolby)
are trying to bring surround sound to those who are unwilling or
unable to incorporate additional (more than two) speakers for
their listening environment. Virtual surround is becoming
especially popular with home computer users who do not wish to
attempt setting up rear speakers at their computer station.
Virtual surround can work surprisingly well albeit with several (severe) limitations. Generally, the "sweet spot" (where you will experience the surround effect) is very, very, small. Usually, only one person in the room can be seated properly to hear the correct surround effect. Also, if you turn your head, that is, look away from the front of the soundstage, the surround effect is lost or, at the very least, the perspective of the sound sources will be incorrect. Finally, rear surround effects are often not very convincing. However, with movies and video game material, where a visual image supplements the surround experience, virtual surround can be quite impressive.
Besides for Dolby, some of the other virtual surround technologies include:
Qsound
QSound is one such company that provides a virtual surround sound
"solution". I personally have had experience with using
QSound as it is incorporated into a computer game I own called
OutWars. The surround effect is quite effective.
SRS (Sound Retrieval System)
Probably one of the first implementations of stereo enhancement
came from Hughes Aerospace when they developed the Sound
Retrieval System. Better known by its acronymn, SRS. The original
intent of SRS was to provide headphone listeners (on airlines) a
more realistic sound experience when watching in-flight movies.
To the best of my knowledge, it never got used for that purpose.
It did develop somewhat of a "cult following" as a
stereo and mono enhancement technique. (Separate processors were
available in the late 80's/early 90's.) SRS is currently
implemented in a number of different products. Sony TVs were the
first to offer SRS, but now it is available on some PCs,
receivers, and various other audio gadgets.
Binaural recordings
If you are unfamiliar with binaural listening, think of it as
"surround sound for headphones". Binaural recordings
usually are made with two microphones placed on the side of a
dummy's head. The microphones are placed at approximately the
same location as where the ears would be. In theory, making such
a recording, then playing it back thru headphones, should provide
a very realistic sound field. Essentially placing you at the
original recording!
Now I have had very little exposure to binaural recordings. The few recordings I have heard, have not overly impressed me when using headphones. However, I have had excellent results when playing binaural recordings thru a matrix surround system! The soundfield is very clean and natural with excellent imaging.
A great source of information of binaural audio can be found at the FAQ site: Binaural for Beginners (FAQ).
Ambisonics
A close "cousin" of matrix surround sound is ambisonics.
Though never very commercially successful, ambisonics has some
very avid promoters. I've never personally experienced any
ambisonic reproduction but you may be interested in learning more
about it. A great starting place is
www.ambisonic.net.
Getting Back to the Music
One of the main points I hope to get across (on this web site) is
that surround sound is great for music. Most stereo recordings,
which are recorded live or rely on ambient sound (such as concert
recordings), benefit significantly from surround sound playback.
However, there have been a considerable number of recordings made
with surround sound specifically in mind.
Several CDs have been made utilizing Dolby Surround. However, I have yet to be impressed with many CD recordings carrying the Dolby Surround logo. On the other hand, most CDs of the Nimbus label are recorded using a technique known as UHJ Ambisonics. The surround effect I've obtained from playing back such ambisonic recordings have been consistently good.
This web page was last updated on: 01/25/20 12:13 PM Pacific Time.